A leaking bath overflow is almost always caused by a failed overflow gasket or a loose overflow assembly, and it usually shows up as damp patches or drips after a deep bath. If you notice active dripping, a sagging or stained ceiling, or water near electrical fixtures, stop using the bath and arrange prompt professional assessment before the damage spreads.
TL;DR:
- Separate fill tests locate the fault: drain level suggests a stopper seal or flange; overflow level suggests the gasket or tube joint.
- Clean the seating surface, match the gasket’s taper, and tighten screws evenly; overtightening can deform the gasket and cause the leak to return.
- Front fit kits may not suit older assemblies; poor access, corrosion, or a returning leak may require full replacement or professional repair.
- Call a licensed plumber for constant or recurring leaks, soft subfloors, mold, or ceiling damage; if water reaches electrical fixtures, isolate circuit power first.
- Gasket and plate parts cost tens of dollars; a straightforward plumber repair typically runs into the low hundreds, with hidden damage or full replacement costing more.
Table of Contents
- How to test whether the overflow is leaking
- Step-by-step DIY: replacing the overflow gasket and reseating the plate
- Tools, parts and rough cost expectations
- When to stop DIY and call a licensed plumber
- Simple upkeep to prevent overflow leaks and reduce future damage risk
- Publisher perspective: how we triage and fix overflow leaks
- What the overflow leak debate gets wrong
- Fixing a stubborn bath overflow leak with Priority Plus Plumbing
- FAQ
- Sources
- Primary building codes and technical guides cited
How to test whether the overflow is leaking
Before you buy parts or call anyone out, two quick fill tests will tell you where the water is actually coming from.
- Drain test: fill the bath a few centimetres, enough to cover the drain flange, and watch underneath for a minute or two. Water here points to a worn stopper seal or a loose drain flange rather than the overflow.
- Overflow test: fill the bath until the water sits just above the overflow opening, hold for a few minutes, then check below the overflow plate and along the waste pipe joints for moisture. A worn gasket only gets wet when the tub is filled to overflow, so this test isolates the gasket or a loose tube joint specifically.
Pattern matters here. If the leak only appears after a bath is filled close to the top, the overflow gasket or joint is the likely cause. If water appears at all times, including with the plug out or the bath empty, you’re more likely dealing with a pressurised supply leak or a separate fault that needs a plumber’s attention.
A torch and an access panel (often a small hatch on the wall behind the bath, or in the room next door) make the overflow test far easier to read. A moisture meter is optional but useful if the wall or ceiling below has already shown a stain, since it tells you whether the material is still wet or just marked from an earlier event.
Pro Tip: Run both tests back to back rather than days apart. Conditions like humidity and ambient temperature can mask a slow drip, and comparing the two results side by side makes the pattern much clearer.
Step-by-step DIY: replacing the overflow gasket and reseating the plate
If your tests point to the overflow gasket, this is one of the more approachable bathroom repairs for a confident DIYer, provided you have reasonable access.
- Prepare the area. Turn off any power to nearby fixtures as a precaution, lay towels or a drop sheet to protect flooring, and gather your tools before you start.
- Remove the overflow plate. Undo the two or three screws holding the plate in place, then gently pull it forward. The gasket and the linkage (on trip-lever models) will usually come with it.
- Extract the old gasket. Work it off carefully with a flat tool, avoiding scratches to the tub finish or the overflow tube opening.
- Clean the seating surface. Wipe away old sealant, soap scum and corrosion so the new gasket sits flush against the tub.
- Fit the new gasket. Many replacement gaskets are tapered, so check the orientation against the old one before fitting. Centre it over the overflow opening and align the plate so the screw holes line up cleanly.
- Tighten evenly. Alternate between screws in small turns rather than fully tightening one at a time. Repair guidance recommends even compression rather than maximum force, since overtightening can deform the gasket and cause the same leak to return within weeks.
- Check the elbow and slip joints. If you have access from behind, hand-tighten any loose slip nuts and confirm the washers inside are seated correctly, not pinched or cracked.
- Retest. Repeat the overflow fill test from the previous section and check below for any sign of moisture before you consider the job finished.
Front-fit gasket kits work on many standard tubs, but they depend on the shape and spacing of the overflow elbow behind the wall. Where the assembly is old, corroded or doesn’t match a standard kit, a full waste-and-overflow replacement, or opening a rear access point, tends to give a more reliable result than forcing a front-fit part to work.
Tools, parts and rough cost expectations
A basic overflow repair doesn’t call for specialised equipment, but having the right pieces on hand before you start saves a second trip to the hardware store.
- Tools: screwdriver set, utility knife, needle-nose pliers, adjustable spanner, torch, and optionally a moisture meter if you suspect hidden damage.
- Parts: a neoprene or rubber overflow gasket, a replacement overflow plate or full waste-and-overflow kit if the old one is damaged, silicone sealant or plumber’s putty, and new screws if the originals are corroded.
On cost, gasket and cover plate parts commonly sit in the tens of dollars, and a plumber replacing the gasket where access is straightforward typically charges in the low hundreds. A full waste-and-overflow replacement, or any job that uncovers ceiling or subfloor damage, generally costs more once that extra work is factored in.
When to stop DIY and call a licensed plumber
Some overflow leaks are simple gasket jobs. Others are a sign of something more serious happening inside the wall, and pushing ahead with a DIY fix in those cases can mask the real problem.
Call a licensed plumber if you notice any of the following:
- An active leak that doesn’t stop regardless of whether the bath is in use, suggesting a pressurised supply fault rather than an overflow issue.
- A sagging, bubbling or stained ceiling below the bathroom.
- Soft or spongy subfloor near the tub.
- Visible mould growth on walls, skirting or the ceiling below.
- A leak that returns shortly after a DIY repair.
- Water tracking near light fittings, powerpoints or other electrical fixtures.
Water reaching a ceiling light or nearby powerpoint is an electrical safety risk first and a plumbing job second, so isolate power to that circuit at the switchboard before doing anything else. While you wait for a plumber, stop using the bath, place bowls or towels to catch any ongoing drips, ventilate the room to slow mould growth, and photograph any staining or damage for your insurer or strata records — for guidance on when mould requires remediation versus regular cleaning, see mould remediation vs cleaning.
Pro Tip: Keep a simple log of when leaks appear, how much water you find, and any changes you notice. It helps a plumber diagnose the fault faster on the first visit.
A professional will typically open the waste-and-overflow assembly from behind, check for hidden moisture along the way, and advise on any ceiling or subfloor remediation needed before closing the wall back up.

Simple upkeep to prevent overflow leaks and reduce future damage risk
Most overflow leaks build up slowly, which means a few minutes of checking each year can save a much bigger repair later.
- Check the overflow plate screws annually for looseness or corrosion, and replace the gasket if it looks worn or compressed.
- Inspect caulk and grout around the tub edge and reseal where it’s cracked or peeling.
- Run a quick overflow fill test once a year to confirm water is draining through the pipe, not behind the tub.
- If you have an access panel, open it occasionally to look for staining, rust or dampness.
If you’re renovating, include a proper access panel behind the bath and choose a durable waste-and-overflow kit with a quality gasket. A framed, lockable access panel costs little to add during a renovation and saves significant disruption later if the overflow assembly ever needs attention. Our bathroom renovation guide covers more on planning this kind of access from the start. Catching a small leak early is almost always cheaper and simpler than dealing with mould or structural damage after months of slow moisture.
Publisher perspective: how we triage and fix overflow leaks
On most overflow jobs we attend, the cause is one of three things: a worn gasket, a corroded or hard-to-reach assembly, or a patch repair from a previous attempt that never sealed properly. Access, more than the fault itself, usually determines how long the job takes and what it costs.
Our approach starts with the same fill tests outlined above, backed by a visual inspection and a moisture check where staining is already visible, before we quote a fixed price for the repair. If you’re booking an inspection, having photos of any staining, a description of when the leak appears, and knowledge of whether there’s an access panel helps us scope the job accurately before we arrive.
What the overflow leak debate gets wrong
Most advice online treats a bath overflow leak as either a five-minute gasket swap or an emergency, with nothing in between. In practice, the test result matters more than the symptom. A damp patch that only appears after a deep bath is a different problem to one that’s there all the time, and the fill tests above take less effort than most people assume before reaching for tools or the phone.

Where conventional advice falls short is in underselling access. A gasket kit bought online assumes a standard elbow and standard spacing, and plenty of older bathrooms don’t have either. Readers who skip the test step and jump straight to fitting a part often end up repeating the job within a year, not because the part was wrong, but because the underlying fault was never confirmed.
If there’s one thing worth prioritising, it’s identifying the pattern before buying anything. A leak that only shows up near the overflow line is worth a DIY attempt. A leak that’s constant, or that’s already left a mark on the ceiling, is worth a professional look before it becomes a bigger repair.
— Peter Honey
Fixing a stubborn bath overflow leak with Priority Plus Plumbing
When a gasket swap doesn’t hold, or access behind the tub is tighter than expected, we offer 24/7 emergency and general plumbing services, with upfront pricing agreed before any work starts.

Our technicians run the same diagnostic checks outlined above, using moisture checks where staining suggests the problem has been running longer than it looks, and we quote a fixed price once the cause is confirmed. Every repair is backed by a workmanship guarantee, and straightforward overflow jobs with good access are usually completed in a single visit.
- Active or worsening leak: book through our emergency plumbing service for urgent assessment.
- Planning a bathroom upgrade alongside the repair: our bathroom and kitchen plumbing page covers waste-and-overflow replacement as part of a wider job.
- Unsure if it’s the overflow or something else: our general plumbing services page covers diagnosis for less urgent cases.
Get in touch through our Priority Plus Plumbing homepage to check availability and book an inspection.
FAQ
Can you seal the overflow drain?
A failed overflow gasket should be replaced rather than sealed over, since silicone alone won’t hold against repeated water pressure. Some installers add a thin bead of plumber’s putty or silicone around a new gasket for extra insurance, but it works alongside a proper gasket, not instead of one.
What is the circle thing in the bathtub?
The circular fitting near the top of the bath, usually with visible screws, is the overflow plate. It covers the overflow drain and, on older tubs, often houses the linkage for a trip-lever style stopper.
How to stop water leaking down the side of a bath?
Water tracking down the side of a bath is usually caused by failed caulk or grout at the tub edge rather than the overflow itself, so check and reseal that joint first. If water still appears after resealing, run the fill tests described above to rule out the overflow gasket or drain flange.
Why is the tub drain leaking?
A leaking drain is most often a worn stopper seal or a loose drain flange, which a simple fill test with a few centimetres of water will usually confirm. If the leak only appears when the bath is filled near the top, the overflow gasket is the more likely cause rather than the drain itself.
Sources
- Part F2 wet-area and overflow protection | CodeMark
- Bathtub overflow drains: gasket leaks and waste kits – InspectandTest
- How to fix a leaky bathtub overflow drain – The Spruce
- Plumbing work requires certification (practical advice) – Builtly
Primary building codes and technical guides cited
- Part F2 wet-area and overflow protection | CodeMark
- Bathtub overflow drains: gasket leaks and waste kits – InspectandTest
- How to fix a leaky bathtub overflow drain – The Spruce
- Plumbing work requires certification (practical advice) – Builtly
- Bathtub overflow gaskets (maintenance tips) – HGTV